The strength of a church is not found in its programs, buildings, or even the charisma of its leadership. It is found in the hands and hearts of those who serve. The body of Christ functions best when every member finds a place to contribute, offering their givings for the building up of the church and the reaching of the community. However, many churches struggle to engage people in meaningful service. Recruiting those who will joyfully and faithfully serve is one of the most difficult challenges church leaders like you face. Some churches find themselves with a small, overburdened core of helpers, while others experience apathy among congregants who seem content to simply attend but not participate. Why is it so difficult to engage people in service? Why do so many efforts to enlist help result in limited or short-lived success?
Part of the problem lies in common mistakes that churches make when seeking to engage people in volunteering. These missteps, while unintentional, can create barriers that discourage participation rather than inspire it. Churches that rely solely on broad announcements, treat service as a task instead of a calling, overwork the same faithful few, or neglect to show gratitude will inevitably struggle to create a culture of joyful service. Thankfully, these pitfalls can be avoided with intentional strategies that cultivate a thriving, engaged team of workers who serve with passion and purpose. When churches shift their approach, they will see the fruit of their efforts, fulfilling the biblical mandate that every believer is called to contribute to the work of God’s kingdom (Ephesians 4:16).
A healthy, growing ministry cannot function without willing hands and committed hearts. Jesus said, “The harvest is plentiful, but the laborers are few” (Matthew 9:37), and this remains true today. However, rather than resigning to frustration, church leaders must take an honest look at their approach to engaging people in service. By addressing common mistakes and implementing better strategies, churches can transform their ability to attract, equip, and retain those who will serve. The following are some of the biggest mistakes churches make when seeking to engage people in ministry and practical solutions to correct them.
Only Asking from the Pulpit
Many make the mistake of relying solely on general announcements from the stage to engage people in serving. A pastor or leader may mention a need during a Sunday morning service, hoping that someone will be moved to step forward. While this approach may yield some response, it is often ineffective in creating long-term commitments. People hear the need, but without a personal connection or clear understanding of what is expected, they often assume someone else will step up or feel uncertain about whether they are the right fit.
A more effective approach is personal invitation. Jesus called His disciples individually, saying, “Follow me, and I will make you fishers of men” (Matthew 4:19). Instead of making broad appeals, leaders should take the time to personally invite people to serve. A face-to-face conversation, a phone call, or a heartfelt email can go a long way in making someone feel seen and valued. It also allows for discussion about how their unique gifts and interests align with the opportunity, increasing their willingness to commit.
Additionally, sharing specific stories about how serving has made an impact can inspire people to step forward. Rather than simply stating a need, churches should highlight testimonies of those who have found joy and fulfillment in serving. When people see the tangible ways that service changes lives, both for those who serve and those they help, they are more likely to see it as an opportunity rather than an obligation.
Making It About Filling a Role, Not a Calling
One of the biggest mistakes churches make in recruiting is presenting service opportunities as just another task to be filled. When people hear that the church “needs” help in a certain area, they often feel like just another number on a list rather than a valuable part of God’s work. Scripture teaches that each person is uniquely gifted by the Holy Spirit for a purpose (1 Corinthians 12:4-7), and if churches fail to communicate that serving is about fulfilling God’s calling rather than simply filling a role, they miss out on engaging people in a meaningful way.
Instead of framing service as plugging holes in ministry, church leaders should focus on helping individuals see where their passions and talents align with the needs of the church. People respond more enthusiastically when they understand that their specific gifts—whether in teaching, hospitality, administration, or creativity—have a divine purpose. When service opportunities are framed this way, individuals are more likely to feel ownership and joy in their contributions, rather than feeling like they are taking on a chore.
One practical way to implement this is through personal conversations and spiritual gift assessments. By engaging people directly and discussing their interests, leaders can guide them into roles where they will thrive. A church that actively helps members discover and develop their gifts will have a team of dedicated servants who see their work as an extension of their faith rather than an obligation.
Furthermore, sharing testimonies of those who have found fulfillment in serving can inspire others to do the same. When people hear stories of how God has used others in ministry, they begin to envision how He might use them as well. These testimonies should not just highlight what was accomplished, but also how serving deepened their faith and strengthened their walk with God.
Ultimately, the goal is to create a culture where serving is seen as a natural outgrowth of a believer’s relationship with Christ. Romans 12:6-8 reminds us that we are all called to serve in different capacities, and when churches emphasize this, they move beyond simply filling spots on a schedule and begin equipping disciples for kingdom work.
Overloading the Willing Few
A common struggle in many churches is that the same small group of dedicated helpers ends up carrying the weight of multiple responsibilities. While their faithfulness is commendable, this pattern often leads to burnout, frustration, and, ultimately, disengagement. Scripture warns against exhausting those who serve: “Let us not grow weary in doing good” (Galatians 6:9). When the burden of ministry is not shared, even the most devoted will eventually reach their limit.
To fix this, churches must be intentional about creating a culture where service is a shared responsibility. One way to do this is by implementing a rotation system, ensuring that no one is serving indefinitely without breaks. Encouraging new participation by offering clear on-ramps, such as short-term commitments or “shadowing” opportunities, can also prevent overloading the few. Additionally, leaders must check in regularly with those who serve to ensure they feel supported, valued, and refreshed rather than drained.
Churches should also examine whether they are truly equipping people for longevity in ministry. Training, mentorship, and team-building initiatives can provide encouragement and support, reducing the risk of exhaustion. If people see that their time and effort are being stewarded wisely, they will be more likely to remain engaged over the long term.
Forgetting to Show Appreciation
When people serve faithfully and feel unseen, they will eventually lose motivation and passion. One of the most common mistakes churches make is assuming that because people are serving God, they don’t need recognition. While it’s true that our ultimate reward comes from the Lord (Colossians 3:23-24), the Bible also teaches us to “encourage one another and build each other up” (1 Thessalonians 5:11). Failing to acknowledge those who give their time and energy to the church can lead to disillusionment and burnout.
A simple and powerful way to fix this issue is through intentional acts of gratitude. A heartfelt “thank you” from a pastor, a handwritten note from a ministry leader, or a public acknowledgment during a church service can go a long way in making people feel valued. These gestures don’t have to be extravagant, but they should be sincere and specific. When people hear exactly how their contributions are making an impact, they feel encouraged and inspired to continue serving.
Beyond verbal recognition, churches should also consider appreciation events. Hosting a volunteer appreciation dinner, an annual celebration, or even a casual coffee meet-up can provide opportunities to express gratitude in a tangible way. These moments allow leaders to personally connect with those who serve, reinforcing that they are an essential part of the church’s mission.
Another way to show appreciation is by investing in those who serve. Providing leadership training, spiritual retreats, or small tokens of gratitude, such as books or devotionals, can communicate that their contributions are both seen and valued. By pouring into them spiritually and emotionally, the church demonstrates that they are not just workers, but cherished members of the body of Christ.
Ultimately, creating a culture of gratitude will transform the church community. When appreciation is embedded into the fabric of ministry, people serve with greater joy and a renewed sense of purpose. Galatians 6:9 encourages us not to grow weary in doing good, but everyone needs encouragement to press on. When the church makes a concerted effort to honor and uplift those who serve, it fosters a thriving, motivated team eager to continue God’s work.
Transforming the Culture of Service
Avoiding these common mistakes can revolutionize the way a church engages people in ministry. When service becomes personal rather than impersonal, when it is framed as a calling rather than a duty, when it is distributed wisely rather than concentrated on a few, and when it is met with consistent gratitude, you will see a transformation in participation and enthusiasm.
As you cultivate a culture of meaningful service, you will experience the blessings that come with a thriving, engaged team. Those who serve will not do so out of obligation, but out of a deep sense of calling and joy. In the end, a church that values and nurtures those who give their time will reap the rewards of a strong, unified body that is equipped to do the work of the kingdom (1 Peter 4:10). By making these necessary shifts, you will not only fill roles but will also build a movement of people eager to serve for the glory of God.
ACS Technologies
ACS Technologies sets a new standard in church technology, offering a holistic suite of solutions that streamline administrative tasks and empower your staff to excel in their roles and your church to excel in your community.
In the ever-evolving landscape of church engagement and management, ACS Technologies rises above the rest. Our comprehensive church solutions, bespoke digital offerings, streamlined communication tools, comprehensive ministry consulting, and training make us the trusted choice for over fifty thousand churches. Experience the ACS Technologies advantage and elevate your church’s online presence, connectivity, and generosity today. Join us in redefining church technology for the digital age, where your ministry’s success becomes our shared mission.
